Currently Being Moderated

A key differentiator between netbooks and notebooks is that notebooks, by and large, provide a lot more internal storage than netbooks.


Western Digital, with an announcement today, may be pushing that delta yet wider.  The company rolled out its WD Scorpio Blue 640-GB hard disk drive in industry-standard 9.5mm, two-disk form factor.


This is a big deal, given the ever-growing need for capacity as the universe of available, high-quality digital media continues to expand.   While it's true that manufacturers could find a way to build netbooks with these drives, the price tag set by Western Digital is $149. That's not much for a drive of that capacity, but it's probably too expensive to be economically realistic for netbooks which, to be competitive, can't usually be priced at more than $350 or $400.


Predictions of a continued explosion in netbook sales have been dominating discussion in this area. But as the economy rebounds, and the market's taste for more graphics and media expands, so will the need for on-board storage.


It's difficult to see how netbooks can keep up with that -- especially when vendors like Western Digital are providing weapons to OEMs and system builders like their 640-GB capacity drive. If we see more high-capacity, mobile drives, it will help notebook sales and hurt netbook sales -- unless storage pricing somehow craters. There are no signs of that happening.

 

Western Digital's announcement is a good sign for notebooks.

Share this blog: Digg   Del.icio.us   Reddit       LinkedIn  


Sep 10, 2009 11:06 AM AECITVP AECITVP    says:

I think you've reached a false conclusion. Netbooks are not about storage any more than they are about processor speed. Netbooks excel as inexpensive, super portable, web appliances. They’re often used as secondary or tertiary PC’s. With  802.11n and 3G support now and HSPA7.2 and WiMAX coming online, we’ll be streaming more content than ever and accessing our data in the cloud, not storing it locally. You’re right, Western Digital’s 620GB hard drive is great news for notebooks but it won’t impact the sale of Netbooks that presently work well with much smaller hard drives.

Sep 10, 2009 11:24 AM emoltzen emoltzen    says in response to AECITVP:

Thanks for the commentary, and good points. The problem is that smart phones do everything netbooks do, short of allowing you to type on a full keyboard - and smart phones fit into your pocket. My iPhone is an "inexpensive, super portable, web appliance." When I need to work on a PowerPoint, watch or edit video, or take a video conference I can't rely on a netbook. I need a full PC - for both storage and performance.

 

(For school kids, to have a cheap access device in a kitchen, or for simple word processing, netbooks may really be a good answer.)

 

I'm also beginning to hear a lot of commentary lately that may be giving "the cloud" more kudos than it deserves at this point. There is too much evidence that performance and reliability let a lot of people down more often than is discussed. (Gmail, Rackspace, Amazon, etc.)